We had been at the lake for three days. The cots smelled of our bodies, the plates were dirty from our food, and the doors snapping constantly as we ran to and from the cabin. We were comfortable at the lake, it was comfortable with us. Every year we greeted the same small patch of water and rocky shore line with the splash of our fishing poles. Every year the lake didn’t disappoint us; it always brought unpredictable weather and great fishing. This year was no exception.
By the third day of our trip, family members were becoming exhausted. Adults slouched in Adirondack chairs as a few boys tossed a football across the yard. Talk had begun to drift toward dinner and what to make when the youngest cousin and the oldest walked side by side down to the docks. No one noticed the two cousins, nor did they pay attention to what they were doing.
At the end of the dock the youngest cousin peered over the edge, biting her lip as she counted the small fish that swam in the shadows. Next to her, the oldest cousin opened a can of worms, pulling out the first one that was found. In a flash, the oldest cousin broke the worm in two, throwing half of the worm back in the can. Once the oldest cousin had the small bit of worm wrapped around the hook on the pink fishing pole, the oldest cousin handed the pole to the young one.
The oldest cousin ducked quickly as the young one pulled the fishing pole over her shoulder, only to drop the line in the water directly below the dock. It was barely a cast and wouldn’t produce any sizable fish but before long the young cousin was squealing with delight as she yanked her line out of the water. Barely hanging onto the hook was a small fish, it could be deemed a minnow if it was any smaller but it had bitten the hook and the young cousin was happy.
As the oldest cousin reached for the line, the fish let go of the hook; it was obvious that the small fish really hadn’t bitten the hook at all but the worm. The fish splashed into the water, spraying both cousins sending laughter into the air. The young cousin began to reel in her line, like she had been taught. When the hook was at eye level, the young cousin held the line out to the oldest one, waiting for the next worm.
“Do you want to put this one on?” The oldest cousin asked. A smile grew on the young one’s face as she handed over her pink fishing pole. Stooping low, near the can of worms, the young cousin lifted out a long worm. “Break it in half.” The oldest cousin told her before looking at the hook. As the oldest cousin turned back to the youngest, a look of horror crossed the young one’s face. Before knowing what happened, the young one stuck out her tongue to produce the guts of the worm mixed with dirt. The oldest cousin could feel her face get warmer as her heart began to pump faster. “Hold on, hold on.” The oldest cousin kept repeating as she set down the fishing pole and flung the bitten in half worm, into the water.
But it was too late, the youngest cousin had begun to cry, grabbing the attention of the adults still hunched over in the wooden chairs. The oldest cousin wiped as much dirt and gut off of the young one’s tongue as possible before the youngest cousin ran away to her mother. Alone on the dock, the oldest cousin looked into the shadowy water where the small fish were eating the half bitten worm.
“And that’s how it all happened. No more, no less.” I turned toward my family. Their stares and vacant expressions told me that they didn’t believe a word that I had to say. “You told her to eat it.” My brother retorted before getting up from the dinner table. “I did not. Besides, she didn’t eat the worm at all; it was still a whole worm when I threw it in the water. It was just bitten in half.” I stumbled over my words, as I tried to recall the exact look of the worm. “She ate it and we all know it,” my dad grabbed his glass pouring himself another drink. I knew that she didn’t eat the worm, even if they didn’t believe me. I looked to my young cousin who sat opposite from me.
She refused to say anything. Every time this story is brought up, she doesn’t say a word. It happened to both of us, why won’t she speak in my defense? I didn’t force her to eat a worm and I know that she didn’t. Does she not speak because she did eat it and I’m just not remembering correctly? She couldn’t have eaten it. It’s not possible. Was it too traumatic of an event and she has suppressed it? I would if I was her. That must be it. What else could it be? From across the table I give a half smile to my young cousin who returns it. Perhaps she does remember and she’s just too smart to get into this argument. Well, one thing is for certain, no matter what version of the story circulates around our house, she and I will always know the truth.